The road less cycled

Mindful meanderings with Daan H. van der Kroon

Lay off on the carbon taxes, already

with 2 comments

A Letter to the Editor I sent while all steamed up after reading the July 6 edition of the Abbotsford News.

I am tired of hearing the policy of pricing carbon dioxide emissions through carbon taxes and carbon trading systems trashed and mis-represented.

Yes, these new polices will have a slight impact on the price of gas at the pump as well as on consumer goods at the store. But this will be nothing compared to the rise in fuel prices we have seen in recent years. I remember when gas sold for 70c/litre. I’m young, obviously – I’m sure there are those who remember gas being half that or less. Now we are seeing double those prices and more. That’s right – a 100%+ increase, incrementally, in a few short years. What sort of reaction did this provoke from consumers?

That’s right; nary so much as a squeak of protest. Barely more than a grumble of discontent. We just took the price hikes square on the chin, and kept right on pumping and pushing that gas pedal.

Compare that to the carbon tax – a miniscule increase by comparison – and you’d be forgiven for thinking the sun would never rise again judging by the outcry in the media.

The difference? The gas price increases we’ve seen, independent of any kind of carbon tax, are market induced, while the carbon taxes are government driven.

When the markets impose price increases, we grin and bear it. Yet when the government enacts proactive policy, such as the carbon tax, an essential component of tackling one of the greatest threats to face mankind, all hell breaks loose. People talk of breaking out the pitchforks and kicking out those bums in elected office -the very ones who actually have the stones to take the necessary steps to combat climate change. (and even for those who do not yet accept the reality of climate change, you must agree that reducing pollution is a positive step).

People, give your heads a shake. What is this holy grail known as “the market”? It is simply the result of unilateral decisions made at the board room level of the top corporations, banks, and yes, some governmental institutions, in tandem with some good ol’ supply and demand. It is not some irresistible force which we must all be slaves to. At the end of the day, it is the consumer who determines how the markets will play out by way of what we do and do not consume.

We all know that oil and gas are limited resouces. Why not begin the shift away from them now, rather than waiting until every last barrel has been extracted from the pristine natural habitats where it is found? Why not embrace change now, and create a gradual transition that is under our control, rather than be shocked when we can no longer live in the high consumptive ways we are so accustomed to?

For once, our governments are taking sensible measures to motivate us to adapt to a different future. Let’s take our heads out of the proverbial tar sands, cut them some slack, and see if we can’t biccycle to work or the grocery store next time around.

Written by streamrambler

July 4, 2008 at 1:06 pm

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Brilliant!

    Bimbeffete

    August 3, 2008 at 12:50 am

  2. NOT BRILLIANT!

    The point isn’t that the taxation is small in comparison to the price flux of supply and demand. The point is that its there in the first place.

    Liberals want to increase taxation on transportation; the nessesity that is the foundation of our economy.

    Don’t get me wrong we need to addapt to a more environmentaly friendly transportation system, but it must be done incrementaly and effectively.

    Carbon Tax dose nothing but draw wealth out of our pockets, to be placed in the hands of government. Ethicly chalanged government at that. It has no practical means to and environmentaly friendly end. Environmental leveys run in the same catagory.

    Why must we here TAX TAX TAX every time we run up against a problem. Has our government lost all of its creativity? Where is the inovation? Where is the vision that these polititions are being paid to possess?

    At a time of economic down turn we can’t have a government who sifens the gas out of our tanks, and scares the heat out of our houses. We need of government of vision who would rather encourage us with tax relief for creating “green” energy, clean fuel, and other inovations that not only save our environment, and help keep our jobs, but bring in new investments and prosperity to our province and our country.

    Let us no longer elect governments who uses fear to steel our money, rather, let us elect one who gives us relief with vision, purpose, and hope.
    Know your options
    Know the BC conservative government.

    A partisan ideologue who can’t spell. Great. Exactly what we need.

    – Daniel

    benjamin besler

    November 3, 2008 at 11:52 pm


Leave a Reply